fbpx

Best Crib Mattress

Last Updated:
Andrew

Introduction

When you have a new baby on the way, there are a million and one things to consider to prepare for their arrival. One of the main things you need to purchase is somewhere for your baby to sleep. This is why you will have to spend some time to find the best crib mattress possible for your little one.

Our team has put in the hard work for you, so all you need to do is worry about the baby. We have the best crib mattresses right here.

In a nutshell

What you need to look out for

Highlights

Just as there are with full-size mattresses, there are a lot of choices when it comes to crib mattresses. Every baby is different, and so is every mattress. Brands are all very conscious nowadays to make sure their products are as safe to use as possible, both in terms of SIDS and keeping the materials they use as natural and hypoallergenic as possible. This is something we always keep in mind when selecting the best crib mattresses possible.

Best Crib Mattress 2019

Our team has put many hours into researching and testing the best crib mattresses on the market to bring together in this guide. Each product listed below comes highly recommended both by us and through multiple positive reviews online. You and your new baby will be able to sleep easy knowing that you’ve made the best decision possible.
1

Milliard Crib Mattress

OUR PICK

Millard Crib Mattress

Our overall rating

4.8 / 5

See how we rate >

Key features

  • Reversible mattress
  • 100% cotton cover
  • 5-star reviews

Great for

  • Babies and toddlers
  • Durability
  • Multiple-child families
The Milliard crib mattress has earned a stellar reputation online thanks to hundreds of 5-star reviews on sites like Amazon, making them a trusted favorite in the market. It is designed to be reversible depending on your baby’s age. There is a firmer side to support your infant while they sleep, and a softer side for when they progress to a toddler that helps to promote proper posture.The cover is 100% cotton and is also waterproof and washable – very important for crib mattresses. The measurements come in at 27.5” x 52” which means it perfectly fits all standard US crib sizes, so is ideal for a second child as you can use it in your older child’s crib instead of needing to purchase a new one.
2

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Our overall rating

4.7 / 5

See how we rate >

Key features

  • 100-night trial
  • Four color choices
  • Breathable mattress

Great for

  • Easy to clean
  • Multiple sleep styles
  • Babies and toddlers
The Newton Baby crib mattress is a popular choice across the web, and it’s easy to see why. Their standard size mattress comes in four different color choices (Cloud White, Moonlight Gray. Sunrise Pink, and Sky Blue) so you can find a design to match the rest of your baby’s nursery. The mattress is 100% breathable, which not only helps to keep your baby cool throughout the night but also helps to keep them safer while they sleep.All their mattresses come with free shipping and they aim to deliver within 3-5 days. They have been specially designed to suit multiple sleep styles to help make your life as a parent easier – not all babies will happily sleep on their back!The cover is made from 100% polyester and can be quickly taken off and machine washed so you can spend less time cleaning and more time with your newborn. And, the 2 stage design helps to increase the life of the mattress by keeping it appropriate for your child into their toddler years.
3

My First Crib Mattress

My First Crib Mattress

Our overall rating

4.5 / 5

See how we rate >

Key features

  • 10-year warranty
  • CertiPUR-US foam
  • Machine-washable cover

Great for

  • Multiple uses
  • Sleep safety
  • Easy maintenance
The crib mattress from My First consists of durable, high-density foam that is extra-firm to help keep your baby safe and comfortable while they sleep. Made of CertiPUR-US foam, it fits all standard US cribs so you won’t need to purchase a new crib if this is not your first child.The mattress is hypo-allergenic, mite-proof and anti-microbial so you can sleep as easily as your baby knowing they are in safe hands. The cover is easily removable and can be machine washed for complete ease of care. A large number of the online reviews speak of the softness of the cover and how much both you, and your baby, will love it.The crib mattress comes with a 10-year warranty, so it’s ideal if you plan on using it for multiple children, as it will really be able to stand the test of time.
4

Graco Premium Crib Mattress

Graco Premium Crib Mattress

Our overall rating

4.3 / 5

See how we rate >

Key features

  • Hand-washable
  • 60-year warranty
  • Trusted brand

Great for

  • Easy set-up
  • Maximizing airflow
  • All crib sizes
Graco has been a recognized and trusted baby product brand for over 60 years and their Graco Premium Crib Mattress is yet another excellent product. It comes delivered in an easy to carry box, which makes it quick and easy to set up in your home. It is advisable to allow around 72 hours for your mattress to fully expand before using it though.Made of high-quality, breathable foam, it maximizes airflow while your baby sleeps, keeping them cool and safe throughout the night. The cover that comes included is water-resistant, removable and hand-washable with cold water and soap so is quick and easy to clean.It is designed to fit all standard US crib sizes and comes with a 6-year limited warranty to cover you well-beyond your baby’s need for it.
5

Dream On Me Crib Mattress

Dream On me Crib mattress

Our overall rating

4.1 / 5

See how we rate >

Key features

  • Antibacterial and waterproof
  • Budget-friendly
  • Hypoallergenic

Great for

  • Easy to clean
  • New families
  • Tried and tested
The Dream on Me crib mattress is a great option for budget-friendly parents looking for a quality product. The mattress is made of 10% vinyl and 90% foam, providing nice firm support for your baby, and is suitable for ages 6 months and up.The antibacterial and waterproof design helps to prevent the build-up of mold, mildew, and odor to help keep your mattress feeling fresh and new throughout your ownership. The cover is also waterproof and is quick and easy to clean with just soap and water.This crib mattress has nearly 3,000 reviews on Amazon with over 70% of them coming in at 5-stars so you can feel safe and secure in your purchase decision.

Crib Mattress Buying Guide

WHICH MATTRESS IS BEST FOR CRIB MATTRESSES

Some crib mattresses come designed to transition with your baby from infancy through to their toddler years – these can be especially useful for those on a budget, as you won’t need to purchase a new mattress as soon as others will. Just make sure you have the firmer side on top when your baby is younger, and only switch to the softer side as they get older.

It’s also important to make sure that any mattress you purchase is as safe as possible. This means it should be firm, CertiPUR-US certified and as breathable as possible.

crib mattress
WHAT YOU NEED TO CONSIDER
When purchasing your crib mattress, there are a few points you’ll need to consider.
 Firmness

Babies need very firm mattresses to keep their developing bones as supported as possible throughout the night. It’s also essential for reducing the risk of SIDS. Softer mattresses can cause the baby’s body to sink too far into the mattress which can lead to overheating or even suffocation. Ideally, your baby should be sleeping on their back, so they’ll need a firm mattress to keep them comfortably in alignment.

 Construction

The size of your mattress should fit snugly in your crib, with space for no more than two fingers to slide around the edges. This helps to stop the mattress from moving during the night, as well as keeping space around the mattress to a minimum – keeping your baby safe. According to US standards, crib mattresses should measure at least 27 ¼” x 51 ¼”, and should be no more than 6” thick.

 Cover

The cover on your crib mattress is almost as important as the inside. Ideally, you’ll want to have a cover that is easy to remove and washable to help keep your mattress as clean as possible. It’s also worth considering the material your mattress cover is made from, as this can make a huge difference. Something soft and hypoallergenic is ideal for most babies.

WHAT ARE THE BEST MATTRESS TYPES FOR CRIB MATTRESSES
Crib mattresses usually come in one of the following types:
Memoryfoam mattress
Foam / Memory Foam

Probably the most popular type of crib mattress on the market right now, foam can be an excellent choice for many parents. Foam mattresses tend to be lighter than innerspring mattresses, which makes them much easier to set up and move. While foam mattresses can vary in firmness, most foam crib mattresses tend towards the firmer end of the scale – which is much safer for infants.

Foam mattresses are also usually the cheaper option, which makes them great for parents on a budget. They are also nice and quiet, so your baby is less likely to be woken up in the night. They do sometimes offer less edge support than innerspring mattresses though, which is something you will need to bear in mind

Innerspring mattress
Innerspring

The other main option for crib mattresses is built with a main layer of support coils and at least one foam layer on top for added comfort. These mattresses tend to be much heavier than foam mattresses, which can make it difficult to remove them for cleaning or airing.

One of the major benefits of using a spring mattress though is the firmness they provide along with the targeted support that babies really need. They also tend to have longer lifespans, which can make them excellent choices for those hoping to reuse the mattress for multiple children.

Other recommended mattress brands

This is a dual-sided mattress that can be used both for your baby both as an infant and when they grow up into a toddler. It is made entirely of plant-based foam, and the cover is non-toxic medical-grade nylon that is water-resistant and odor-free. Because this mattress is made of foam, it only weighs around 10lbs so is easy to install and move.
Sol-Organics
This innerspring crib mattress is made from natural, organic materials and a layer of GOTS-certified wool that acts as a fire barrier. The springs are supported by a layer of breathable and natural coconut coir. The cover is made from organic cotton that can be spot cleaned. But, it is worth noting that it can’t be removed so you will probably need to purchase an additional cover to keep the mattress in tip-top shape.

OUR PICK

Best Crib Mattress 2019

1

Milliard Crib Mattress

OUR PICK

Millard Crib Mattress

Our overall rating

4.8 / 5

See how we rate >

Key features

  • Reversible mattress
  • 100% cotton cover
  • 5-star reviews

Great for

  • Babies and toddlers
  • Durability
  • Multiple-child families
The Milliard crib mattress has earned a stellar reputation online thanks to hundreds of 5-star reviews on sites like Amazon, making them a trusted favorite in the market. It is designed to be reversible depending on your baby’s age. There is a firmer side to support your infant while they sleep, and a softer side for when they progress to a toddler that helps to promote proper posture.The cover is 100% cotton and is also waterproof and washable – very important for crib mattresses. The measurements come in at 27.5” x 52” which means it perfectly fits all standard US crib sizes, so is ideal for a second child as you can use it in your older child’s crib instead of needing to purchase a new one.

Top FAQs

What is a dual-sided crib mattress?

Some brands we have mentioned above offer a dual-sided crib mattress. What this means is that one side has been designed for young babies and is firm and supportive to help keep them in place and support their developing bones, and the other is softer and designed for toddlers. Toddlers don’t need as firm a mattress as babies do, and this is around the age where they will start sleeping in multiple different positions, so having a softer mattress will help keep them comfortable throughout the night.

What kind of mattress cover should I look for?

When purchasing a crib mattress, you want to make your life as easy as possible. One of the best ways to do this is to ensure that your mattress cover is as easy to maintain as possible. The majority of brands will come with a removable mattress cover that can be washed either by hand or in a washing machine. Ideally, you’ll also want a cover that can be quickly wiped clean to help reduce your cleaning time.

As you shouldn’t overload your crib with blankets and pillows, you’ll also want the mattress to be soft to the touch to ensure your baby is as comfortable as possible throughout the night.

What kind of crib mattress are best for preventing SIDS

One of the biggest worries for most parents is the risk of SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome). While it’s an uncomfortable topic to talk about, it is a vital consideration when choosing which crib mattress to purchase.

Firmness is one of the most important factors. Crib mattresses should be very firm to stop the infant from sinking into the bed and risking suffocation. It is also important to keep babies cool, as overheating can be a contributing factor. So, mattresses that focus on breathability and airflow are important too.

What certifications should I look out for?

We understand how important it is to know that your baby is sleeping on a safe and regulated crib mattress. There are long lists of possible certifications out there, and it can be confusing knowing which ones you need to look out for.

If you’re buying a foam mattress, make sure the foam they use is CertPUR-US certified. This means that the foam used doesn’t contain potentially harmful materials like lead or formaldehyde. Every crib mattress should also be GREENGUARD Gold-certified meaning they carry minimal emissions of volatile organic compounds or VOCs that can carry health risks.

How much does a good crib mattress cost?

Prices vary across the board, but there are a few general rules that tend to apply. Innerspring mattresses are usually cheaper, with foam mattresses costing a little more. It’s also worth remembering that if you want to opt for organic materials, you’ll probably end up spending a little extra as well. Prices can range anywhere from $75 to $400+, so it’s worth doing your homework if you’re budget conscious.

To wrap it up

Conclusion

Unlike full-size mattresses, you won’t need to use your crib mattress for too many years. Despite this, the majority still come with warranties of up 10 years, so you know you won’t have to worry about needing to replace it. If you really want to get the most out of your crib mattress, then purchasing a dual-sided mattress is your best idea as these can be used right through the toddler years as well.